First of all I invite you to take a look at this: http://www.chick.com/reading/tracts/0046/0046_01.asp
Talking about this comic should get me started up this month.

So, here we have it. A chick-tract. About Dungeons and Dragons. What to do now?
Thinking about it I do not know where to start. There is so much I can say about this thing. Of course, saying what I do not like about it is very cheap and easy. Saying what I do like about it would be much more of a challenge. But that is quite hard, and I have been quite busy lately, so I think I'll make it an easy to write column this month (yes, AGAIN) and burn the thing down. It's probably what you expect of me anyway. And it's much more fun. Although I won't burn it literally, because it's on my computer.

Immediately when I read this, I noticed what a strange vision on role-playing this man has. I mean, I guess about 99% of the role-players are man, so how does he even come up with the idea of showing us a role-playing-community consisting of mostly women? And a woman DM-ing? What are the odds about that? And who ever had to leave a party because his/her character died? And how big would the risk be exactly that someone commits suicide because his/her character dies? I'm pretty sure the numbers that are the answers to this questions will show us that the image of Mr. Chick about role-playing is a bit off.
And what about real powers that you get with a cleric at level 8? Let's look it up. Ah, level 4 spells! Oh no! Air Walk! Control Water! Cure Critical Wounds! Death Ward! Dimensional Anchor! I must burn this book! I must... I must... wait a minute... These spells can't be used in real life! You can't use mind bondage on your father for real so he will buy D&D stuff for you! That way we rpg-ers already would be terribly rich! That way a role-player would be president of the United States!

I think the most terrible thing Mr. Chick does is once again making believe that role-players get dragged into a real occult scene. D&D would be 'an intense occult training'. Well, in reality I think that if one of us went to a real witches coven and tell them: "Hello, I'm ready to join you after months of occult training through D&D!" they would either laugh at you REAL hard or start to kick you after feeling to be ridiculed. Of course, ridiculing them would not be such a bad thing, but I wouldn't go to them for real, though.

I believe Mr. Chick has missed a vital part about the players handbook, at page 6. "'This gave is fantasy" it says. Well, actually I believe Mr. Chick has not seen the Players Handbook. Actually I believe he does not know much about role-playing in reality.
I myself am a church-going Christian. I also play D&D. D&D, after all, is FANTASY. It's as wrong as reading a fantasy-book in my eyes. Because one aspect about fantasy is that it IS NOT REAL. Yes, not all that hard to understand now, is it? It is just not real. The magic is very unlike occult magic. It's just old-fashioned bashing the bad guy with magic missiles and fireballs and stuff!

So I think it's just as with lots of other things: it's in your own hands. If you don't believe it is real than it's a very relaxing hobby of escaping in another world. Just like watching a movie or reading a book. As soon as you start thinking it's real or it's starts to take over your life, then you should watch it and realise it's only fantasy. I don't want any of you out there to start throwing fireballs around for real!

So I don't think role-playing is more wrong than acting and reading fantasy, of which it seems to be some sort of crossover. Mr. Chick's attack on fantasy does not seem to be very relevant because of the ridiculously wrong image he seems to have on the subject. Maybe some people do find it easier to start with real occult business after having started with D&D. But then in my opinion only the step from fantasy to reality is where the person takes a wrong step. Youth might be triggered more easily to get interested in real occult behavior by the growth of magic on tv, movies and games these days, but do not judge the role-players that do know the difference of fantasy and reality.
To all the people that do not know this difference I have one last message: PLEASE NOTICE THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN FANTASY AND REALITY WILL YOU? Thanks.

Back to Philosophers Guild

Home | Submit content | Contact | Legal info | Top of page

This website © Copyright 1999-2008, Arjan Wardekker.
All rights reserved.
All trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners.