By: Bob Luigjes
Product Author: n/a
Lord of the Rings, the first part: The fellowship of the ring, is the
movie I saw. I'd like to post a review about it here. I'm not a good writer, I
just post what I liked and disliked about the movie.
I heard, before I saw the movie, about things which were different in the movie
compared with the book. I read the book twice (one time in English, one time in
Dutch) and I will certainly read it more times in the future, because it's a
very good book. But I was talking about the movie. Of course there are
differences with the book and the film version of the book. But I heard that
Arwen would do a great deal, actually I was told that she would go with the
fellowship of the ring, towards Mordor. Luckily that wasn't so, she did more
then in the book, but she didn't join the company of nine. So I was relieved
A major difference was the departure of the hobbits from the Shire. They went
away immediately after Gandalf showed Frodo the markings in the ring. They
didn't go through the forest of Tom Bombadil either. That's a bit of a shame,
but they can't put everything of the book in a movie of three hours, so I can
There were a few mistakes in the movie which have nothing to do with the book
as well. Gandalf, for example, was fighting Saruman. Saruman took his staff.
When Gandalf was trapped at the top of the tower, he didn't have his staff
back. He escaped with the help of an eagle. But in Rivendell he just got his
staff back again.
There were good things in the movie as well. When Bilbo wanted to take the ring
back from Frodo, in Rivendell, his face changed for a short while, it was the
face of a wrinkled creature with a desiring look in it's eyes. That was filmed
well, I think. There were more things filmed well.
Another good point for me was that they didn't have the movie ended at the same
time as the first part of the book ends. They took a little of the second part
as well, in which Boromir dies heroically and Aragorn, Legolas and Gimli decide
what to do. That's a good ending of the first part I think.
All in all, the differences with the book were not as big as I thought and was
the movie well filmed, with good effects. I'm surely looking forward to the
Back to Philosophers Guild
This website © Copyright 1999-2011, Arjan Wardekker.
All rights reserved.
All trademarks and copyrights are the property of their respective owners.